Practice tool
Test Evidence Assessment
Version 1.0 · Tool & checklist
Review report identity, method, scope, results and the limits of a conformity conclusion.
Set the review scope
State the product decision before assessing the report. A development comparison, regulatory submission and incoming acceptance can require different evidence. Use this tool alongside the actual test method and program conditions.
Working record
| Assessment field | Evidence to inspect | Conclusion to record |
|---|---|---|
| Decision | Requirement and acceptance purpose | Question the report must answer |
| Product identity | Model, revision and critical construction | Match to supplied configuration |
| Sample selection | Selector, population and sampling basis | Representativeness and limitations |
| Laboratory | Location and relevant scope or recognition | Competence for the actual work |
| Method | Designation, edition and test conditions | Match to controlling requirement |
| Deviations | Omitted tests or departures | Effect on the conclusion |
| Results | Values, limits and observations | What was demonstrated |
| Uncertainty | Reported uncertainty and decision rule | Treatment at acceptance boundaries |
| Authenticity | Issuing record and verification route | Evidence of genuine issue |
| Continuing coverage | Changes, validity and surveillance | Coverage of current supply |
| Disposition | Accept, seek clarification or obtain evidence | Reviewer, authority and reasons |
Read the complete report
Review annexes, qualifications and sample descriptions with the results. A cover-page pass statement is insufficient where the tested configuration or method differs from the requirement. Record any limitation in the final decision.
Resolve differences
Seek clarification from the appropriate issuing organization or technical authority. Additional testing should answer a defined question. Do not commission a repeat test merely to replace an inconvenient result without addressing its cause.
Authorize the conclusion
Record the configuration, population and conditions covered. Keep the reviewed report with the decision. Read Reviewing Test Reports and Certification Evidence.